Acidity of Carboxylic Acids

Carboxylic acids are, by definition, Brønsted acids that can donate a proton to ther species with lone pairs.
Ionization of RCOOH in water

They are generally weak acids (vs. the hydronium ion), so the equilibrium above lies far to the left.  For something like acetic acid, the pKa is 4.75, so K for the above expression is 10-4.75, which is about 0.00001. (You have probably considered in General Chemistry the problem of vinegar--a 5% to 8% by weight solution of acetic acid in water. This works out to be approximately 1 M; the expected, and observed, pH is 2.4.)

However, carboxylic acids are much more acidic than alcohols (pKa = 16-18).  One explanation for this is the resonance delocalization afforded by the carbonyl group:
 

Top:  R=tert-BuResonance in a carboxylate ion vs. none in an alkoxide

Bottom:  R=tert-Bu

Turn on ESP maps
Note how much more concentrated on oxygen the charge is for tert-butoxide than for the carboxylate; this is the impact of resonance delocalization of the electrons in the carboxylate ion.

Black background
White background


 Use the structures below to examine the impact of structure on C-O and C-C bond lengths.

Blengths.pdb

Turn on the distance monitor with the button below, then select a set of bonds. Then click on any two atoms; the distance will be displayed on the status bar of your browser.

Turn on distance monitor
Select carboxyl groups
Select alkoxy C-O's
Select Methyl-C bonds
Reset

 
 (This is not the entire story; the electron withdrawing nature of the CO group helps, compared to the electron donating nature of the R group.  A hair-splitting question is whether the resonance in the carboxylic acid is as important as the resonance in the carboxylate.)

Go on to Acidity Page 2.