To tell the difference between these we use a measurement of Kinetic Isotope Effects. In this kind of system, molecules with a heavy isotope (13C or 2H) will react a little bit faster or slower than the "normal" isotope, if they are on a position that is undergoing chemical change in the transition state. We measure the "KIE" by running the reaction to a known level of completion, and measuring the isotopic distribution compared to that in unreacted alkene — the buildup of the heavy isotope is related to the ratio of rates for heavy and light isotopes. A large KIE (much different than 1.000) means the center is undergoing extensive change in bonding at the transition state; a small KIE means any change happens after the transition state.
|
Results:
Hα
|
Hβ c
|
Hβ t
|
Cα
|
Cβ
|
Calculated
|
Concerted [3+2]
|
0.909
|
0.912
|
0.921
|
1.025
|
1.024
|
Stepwise, 1st Step is the TS
|
0.892
|
0.957
|
0.972
|
1.050
|
1.026
|
Stepwise, 2nd step is the TS
|
0.880
|
0.964
|
1.094
|
0.989
|
1.039
|
Experimental Results (± 0.005)
|
0.907
|
0.918
|
0.925
|
1.027
|
1.027
|
|