Navigate back to the activity.
Visualizing the fit of a power series approximation to a goven function.
Convergence for a power series.
Estimated Time: 20 minutes
Students have already calculated the coefficients for a power series expansion. Students plot several terms of the expansion against the original function in order to judge how well the approximation fits the original function.
This activity is a good followup to Calculating Coefficients for a Power Series.
This activity is designed to be a soft introduction to Mathematica or Maple. The notebook/worksheet is already prepared, but is missing some information which students will need to fill in. They will also need to learn how to step through a notebooks/spreadsheet. Students should be able to calculate coefficients for a power series expansion and they need to have the series expansion for $\sin(\theta)$ available.
No introduction is needed - students can jump right in!
Students have to modify the worksheet in order to plot approximations better than 3rd order. Students who are uncomfortable with Maple (or equivalent) may have a little trouble.
Students are asked to determine how many terms are needed in the approximation in order to fit the $\sin{\theta}$ function from $0$ to $\pi$. Students should be encouraged to explore higher order approximations.
This activity leads into a nice discussion of idealizations and making approximations. The question of “How many terms do I need to keep in my approximation?” is related to the question of “What domain do I care about?”
Most students at the middle division level are familiar with small-angle approximations and the example of simple harmonic motion of a pendulum. This activity illustrates nicely how small your angle must be in order for the approximation $\sin{\theta}\approx \theta$ to make sense.
You can also discuss some nice sense-making activities. One such example is being able to tell if you've got the sign wrong for a particular term - if it makes the approximation worse (the approximation diverges from the original function faster than it did with fewer terms), then you may have made a sign error.
This activity is part of a sequence of activities addressing Power Series and their application to physics. The following activities are part of this sequence.
Preceding activities:
The Distance Between Two Points - Star Trek: This kinesthetic activity has students work together to resolve a given problem using geometry which opens the class to a discussion about position vectors and how to generalize the $\frac{1}{r}$ factor to $\dfrac{1}{|\vec{r}-\vec{r}'|}$.
Calculating Coefficients for a Power Series: This small group activity has students work out the expansion coefficients of a familiar function, $\sin(\theta)$, which gives them more experience working with power series.
Follow-up activity:
Electrostatic Potential Due to Two Point Charges: This small group activity has students apply what they know about power series approximations to find a general expression and asymptotic solution to the electrostatic potential due to two point charges.